Just a quick post to share info about a good 9 MHz crystal sold by
Mouser Electronics.
I last purchased
batches of crystals for xtal IF filters back in 2014. Since then,
I’ve bought various 1 off xtals for micro controller clocks, but
these were never critical parts. Now in 2025, I felt a freeze frame
effect – a huge difference – Crystals cost more, less IF choices
seem available; and now, the mini- HC49 or SMD versions seems more
popular than the full size HC49 variants. All this makes sense in
a SMD/digital world.
Further, I randomly swept some of
the smaller sized rocks that I had ~recently ordered and I seemed to see more
spurs, plus, low Qul (< 70K in 3 cases ) -- at least in the
handful of crystals that I tested.Your own results may vary.
I've
already wrote about worsening
access
to xtals
for filters
in
some areas of
the world
–
we are pampered with Mouser and Digi-Key in
North America.
In parts of Eastern Europe where
I have a couple of contacts,
some analog builders find 3 or 4 xtals that are the same frequency inside a
bunch of old
computers and desolder them. Forget about frequency matching multiple xtals –
that’s for “ rich people”.
Today, If
you count currency exchange, shipping and perhaps tariffs, this rings
even truer. The days of ordering a batch of 35-40 crystals to make "1 good“ crystal filter seems a costly adventure for some builders.
I wanted to ply a specific 9 MHz crystal made by IQD - their 449-LFXTAL064523BULK (Mouser Electronics number). I wanted a maximum of 3 crystals in my filter – also 1 for the BFO. I prefer less poles – plus also a BW of 400 - 500 Hz for my CW receivers. I detest aural ringing from group delay in my xtal filters.
In my active audio filters, I now choose a Bessell response to get a maximally flat group delay to give you some added context about my preferences regarding filter group delay.
IQD 449-LFXTAL064523BULK
How did I learn about this particular crystal? On his website, Wes has pdf files on how to make crystal ladder filters. 1 of them is a file about making simple 9 MHz crystal filters – he actually relaxes a little bit on the equations/math for newcomers on this file -- and it’s a great file. Thanks Wes!
The 9 MHz crystal Wes uses on this paper is this particular Mouser part: 449-LFXTAL064523BULK . When I ordered them on Feb 5th – they had only 3 in stock !!! My xtal filter was made from those 3 crystals that arrived 2 days later.
I also had other IQD (Wurth Electronics) crystals in other frequencies ordered from Mouser long ago including 7.68 MHz, 7.3728 MHz, 4.9152 MHz and 2 other frequencies, so I felt confident IQD crystals are both suitable + economical for RF experimenters like me.
Before I measured my xtal parameters using the G3UUR method plus hand calculations. I exactly copied Wes’ simple CW filter capacitor values as a curious experiment. Wes only showed simulations – however, from experience; software can not simulate all the stray capacitance from the IF amp, coils, connectors, etc. But it’s close enough for jazz.
Above — Snippet of my IF stage within my receiver. Filter input /output Z = 50 Ω .
Above — Sweep of my 3 xtal filter. Span = 40 KHz Bandwidth = 449 Hertz due to different crystal parameters than the source article - but still OK for me.
For 3 random crystals (unmatched) – I think it looks OK. The losses are over stated in my sweeper due to extra attenuator padding -- I carefully measured the filter insertion loss at 3.89 dB for these 3 random, unmatched crystals.
Above — Sweep of my 3 xtal filter. Span = 10 KHz
Back Order
At the time of my order, I also back ordered 20 more 449-LFXTAL064523BULK crystals.
Mouser evidently orders these crystals in batches of 1K from their supplier. I feel glad that IQD (Wurth Electronics) are still making them. I received these 20 back-ordered crystals last week & measured the Qul of 3 of my xtals which averaged ~135K. Good enough for CW and SSB filters alike.
Curiously, when my xtals arrived on March 11, Mouser had 972 remaining in stock. When I checked again about 1 week later --- they had 0! Mouser seemingly ordered another 1000 from the factory and they will arrive near the end of April. I wonder how long this stock will last?
If you need xtals for IF filters in future projects – perhaps now might be a time to buy some?
Best!